Happily Ever After: Ranking the Disney Princess Live-Action Remakes
Disney’s animated princess movies are the pinnacle of its Renaissance era, otherwise known as the House of Mouse’s golden age, when they returned to producing the most commercially successful and critically acclaimed animated features. These films have enchanted audiences for decades, so it’s no surprise that Hollywood began rummaging through Mickey’s vault and brought many of them to life with big-budget live-action remakes.
From dazzling visuals equipped with impressive CGI effects to fresh takes on beloved characters, these films recapture the magic of the originals, igniting nostalgia among long-time Disney fans, all the while introducing them to a new generation.
But not all of them have lived up to fairy-tale expectations. While some have soared to new heights, others had fans waiting for a different kind of Happily Ever After.
In honor of the premiere of the live-action remake of Disney’s very first princess, Snow White, we figured it’s about time we ranked the films released so far. However, we’re only including the official Disney Princesses, which means movies like “Enchanted” — although a clever and magical story that combines elements from various Disney Princess films will not be included.
Without further ado, here’s our ranking of live-action Disney Princess movies from least enchanting to most magical!
#8 Mulan (2020)
Starring: Yifei Liu, Gong Li, and Donnie Yen
"Mulan" follows the story of a young woman who disguises herself as a man in the imperial army to take her father’s place in the war. She’s the first Disney Princess who wasn’t based on a fairytale but a Chinese legend and continues to be a shining role model for girls everywhere as she taught us that the “flower that blooms in adversity is the most rare and beautiful of all.”
The remake had been highly anticipated, considering there was much to love about the original 1998 classic, from the catchy songs to the action-packed storyline. However, the 2020 live-action film directed by Niki Caro strayed far away from the source, removing the things that made the original so enjoyable in the first place.
Although the battle sequences were well shot and at par with popular Chinese action films, the film didn’t have the comic relief that was provided by Eddie Murphy’s character, Mushu — and more importantly, the songs. How on Earth do you expect us to defeat the Huns without the “I'll Make a Man Out of You” montage?
While the changes made to the plot were admirable as it was intended to highlight women empowerment and be closer to the source material, it was devoid of its iconic humor, making the film a little less magical. We did give points, however, for having Christina Aguilera sing the beloved song “Reflection” again for the end credits.
#7 Snow White (2025)
Starring: Rachel Zegler, Gal Gadot, Andrew Burnap
It was only about time that Disney’s OG princess got her own live-action movie. Don’t get us wrong, the story has seen various remakes through the years such as Lily Collin’s “Mirror, Mirror” and Kristen Stewart’s “Snow White and the Huntsman” among the popular ones, but to have a Disney-made one, honoring the original 1937 classic would be a first.
Theater actress Rachel Zegler played the titular role, which we believed was a good choice considering she had the pipes for it and brought a refreshing take on the role. Gal Gadot as the Evil Queen was unexpected but very much welcomed by Disney fans, intrigued to see her in a villain role after having played a superhero for DC Comics. With a good cast and the promise of new songs, where did it go wrong?
“Snow White” suffers from the same thing “Mulan” did, but instead of just straying from the source material, we felt it altered Snow White’s character a little too much. Although the intention was to make her stronger and more independent, which was supported by a good backstory, this Snow White felt a little too modern, which can be both a good and bad thing. We’re still torn about whether or not it’s a win, but it was an enjoyable film, nonetheless, and the new songs were a wonderful addition to the classic.
#6 Maleficent: Mistress of Evil (2019)
Starring: Angelina Jolie and Elle Fanning
Now you might be wondering, isn’t Maleficent a villain? Yes, but Disney decided to make this iconic antagonist more relatable and sympathetic by giving her own film but still following the timeline of the original “Sleeping Beauty” film.
This isn’t that film, however, but its sequel, and unlike its predecessor, the plot falls short, and the character development could’ve used a little bit more adjustment. Aurora (Elle Fanning), who is now queen of the Moors, saw very little development from what we already knew about her while the villain in this film — although slightly more evil than what we expected this company to develop, being a queen who wanted to commit genocide, didn’t quite live up to its potential.
On the other hand, just like the first film, it’s visually stunning with an impressive ensemble of actors who actually look like their animated counterparts. It might not be the best, but definitely better than most of the sequels Disney produced in the 90s.
#5 Aladdin (2019)
Starring: Will Smith, Mena Massoud, and Naomi Scott
“Aladdin” was a magical surprise. It was interesting to see how everyone kind of hated it the moment the teaser trailer came out, only to be pleasantly swept off their feet after watching the film in its entirety. In fact, it flew past the billion-dollar mark at the worldwide box office, making it one of the most commercially successful movies on this roster.
And what’s not to love? Not only did Mena Massoud look like the handsome, dimpled thief from Agrabah, but he also sounded like him! Will Smith also defied expectations and really shone as the Genie, much to the fans’ delight. Princess Jasmine (Naomi Scott) also got a little bit more screen time, plus a well-deserved solo song, which would’ve been really good if it hadn’t clashed with the original soundtrack’s sound. It seemed a little bit too modern, despite being a good pop song.
Although “Aladdin” was a good film in terms of paying tribute to the original, it fell short on originality; the changes made neither added nor subtracted value to the franchise. Do we like it better than the animation? Not really. Is it one of the better live-action remakes? Absolutely! 10/10 would still get on that magic carpet ride.
#4 The Little Mermaid (2023)
Starring: Halle Bailey, Jonah Hauer-King, and Melissa McCarthy
It felt like forever until we saw this feature on the screen, considering it was the film that got caught up in the pandemic, and filming took longer as it had to be paused mid-way. Everyone had been skeptical about it mainly because they had cast a black woman as our favorite red-headed mermaid — a character assumed to be white since it was originally based on a tale from Denmark. But some fans have argued, she’s a mermaid, a fictional character. Does race matter?
As a matter of fact, it does. But not for the reason you think. We believed representation mattered, and Halle Bailey completely understood the assignment when she switched her legs for a tail in this role. It made sense why Disney had chosen her, considering she had the most beautiful voice and portrayed Ariel’s spirit so effortlessly; it was like the character literally came to life before our eyes.
The movie stayed true to the original but with minor changes and additions that gave more depth to the characters we know and love. Take Prince Eric’s soaring solo “Wild Uncharted Waters” which gave us a little bit more insight into how he felt after being saved, and his love for sailing and expeditions; or that adorable interaction before “Kiss the Girl” when Ariel tried to teach Eric how to say her name (IYKYK).
“The Little Mermaid” successfully revived a classic tale with improved character development, a handful of new iconic songs, and thought-out interactions but surprisingly falls short on the visual aspect. It was impressive how they managed to make an entire movie set underwater, and we know nothing about CGI, but that would’ve been a difficult feat. However, it didn’t look as realistic as we’d hoped and didn’t give us that feeling of being submerged under the sea. Nonetheless, this film deserves a high spot on this list for its diversity and polished storytelling.
#3 Maleficent (2014)
Starring: Angelina Jolie and Elle Fanning
Maleficent may have been a villain, but she’s Disney royalty in her own right, having been a box-office success in 2014, which led to the string of live-action films on this list. This movie is a retelling of the classic tale and narrates the story from the perspective of the villain — a refreshing concept that earned its spot in the Top 3.
We believe Disney made a good choice telling the story from Maleficent’s point of view as this opens up possibilities for her character development. In the original animated feature, she was just the “Mistress of All Evil” with little to no background on why or how she came to take on the title. In the movie, Disney told us about Maleficent’s origins as a fairy with massive wings as well as her conflicted relationship with King Stefan — who was portrayed as the villain in this story. We also loved Maleficent and Aurora’s dynamic in this tale, how the plot humanizes her with a compelling character arc.
It's far from the tale or villain we know, but it’s new and intriguing, and opened the possibility for other characters — whether villains or supporting roles — to get their turn in the spotlight.
#2 Beauty and the Beast
Starring: Emma Watson, Dan Stevens, and Luke Evans
There may be no such thing as perfection, but Disney’s live-action remake of “Beauty and the Beast” came close. Like “Aladdin,” the film retained most of its original elements, from the character looks and design to the music and storyline. There were only subtle nuances in this tale, like how they made Belle more of an inventor than just a girl who loves to read, and was truly someone who thought outside the box, which better explained why everyone in town thought she was odd. There were also visual flashbacks about Belle’s mother and the Beast prior to the curse, which were only told by a narrator in the original animation. This improved character development, making them more relatable and worth rooting for.
These subtle changes also filled up the gaps in the original animated feature and answered some of our questions, like why everyone forgot about the castle and its occupants. Or why Mrs. Potts, Lumiere, and Cogsworth stay loyal to the prince despite him being, well — mean.
Perhaps its strongest change was the new music made by no other than legendary composer Alan Menken, who somehow made his original score even better with the addition of “Days In the Sun”, “Evermore,” and “How Does a Moment Last Forever.” Our favorite tracks were still heard throughout the film, given a more vibrant and soaring sound, highlighting its magical aspect. It flooded us with sweet nostalgia and had us crying at the end of the film. Yes — we’re talking about that scene just as the last petal fell. Watch it to know what we mean!
#1 Cinderella (2015)
Starring: Lily James, Cate Blanchett, Helena Bonham Carter, and Richard Madden
Ten years since it was released and this live-action remake remains untouched as the best among the rest, and we believe many would agree. It exemplified what these remakes could do when done well, and what can make these adaptations enjoyable for fans and new audiences. Like “Beauty and the Beast,” “Cinderella" retained all the elements that made it magical and beautiful, which made it a nostalgic masterpiece. Its modern take was present in the way technology was used to enhance scenes such as Cinderella’s iconic dress transformation, which instantly made the audience feel as if they were seeing it for the first time.
It had a slightly longer run time, which gave more time to develop Prince Charming’s character, who had always been a mystery since he barely had any dialogue in the animation. It also deepened our understanding of Cinderella’s character by showing us scenes from before she was orphaned and how she lived by her mother’s words, which led her to become so kind that she allowed her stepmothers and sisters to treat her badly.
The actors were all well-suited for the roles, with Cate Blanchett and Helena Bonham Carter, in particular, shining in their roles as the stepmother and Fairy godmother. Lily James was a gem and truly stepped into the role of the kind maiden in glass slippers, as well. The costumes were divine, and the set design was remarkable. It’s pure Disney magic from start to finish; a masterpiece in its own right. We just know people wouldn’t mind watching it over and over again the way they do with the original animated features.
You can watch all these fantastic Disney live-action movies on Disney+. You can also follow the platform on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok for more magical Disney films and shows.
Get the latest curated content with The Beat Asia's newsletters. Sign up now for a weekly dose of the best stories, events, and deals delivered straight to your inbox. Don't miss out! Click here to subscribe.
